- Amy's Testimonials
- Trip Advisor Reviews
You will never eat a more perfect apple than at Amy's. First, you are idly strolling the streets of downtown Cedarburg. Suddenly you are sidetracked by what can only be described as 'The Mecca of Carmel Apples' towering before you. You are in its tractor beam and it is pulling you in. Do you know why? Because there are Caramel Apples with Gummy Worms and Dirt Cake topping, Cashews, Chocolate and Chili Powder, White Chocolate and Apple Pie Spice, Black Forest, the list goes on and on. You have to see it to understand.
That old adage: You're like a kid in a candy shop - it's a literal statement here. You will most likely ping pong between the racks of apples in the front window, tissue in hand, trying to whittle down your apple choice. Don't sweat it babe, you can't go wrong. Each apple is huge in its diameter, they are heavy and dense Granny Smith's and when you cut into them you will find they are in pristine condition with nary a blemish. How they pick such magnificent apples is a mystery to me. Surrounding the luscious apple is a very generous layer of sweet, buttery, rich caramel and if you went for one of the topped apples, another layer of cookies, nuts, spices, candies, etc. Picking up the apples sometimes requires a backhoe due to their heft. One is certainly enough for two people to share, although sharing, eh, its overrated.....
When finally, you pick your apple, you bring it to the checkout counter, and they box it up for you in a perfectly cute bronze, cube. It's so exciting, getting that little cube, I feel like I am getting a birthday present or something. I need to warn you though, most people on their way up to the counter with their apple in hand will no doubt get distracted by the chocolates that flank the walls and grace the glass counter cases. Luckily, I am a mutant who loathes chocolate and therefore am impervious, however I've seen my fair share of patrons unable to resist the chocolate temptations.
The staff is always nice, and jovial. Although, I suspect they have a contact high being surrounded by all that sugar. I like to imagine them swirling around the kitchen like magical pixies making all the candies and apples with a dusting of love and a spoonful of sugar. Shhh, shhhh, shhhh....don't ruin this little break with reality.
If an apple a day keeps the doctor away a diet of Amy's apples should make me the healthiest woman alive right? - Jessica O. Milwaukee WI
Thank you so much for the beautiful fashion themed sweets! You did a great job. Everything was so beautiful and delicious, I'll be back again!!!! - Debra L.
Well done. I received my two apples on time for our Anniversay!! Could not be happier. SHE loved the apples. Keep up the good work. - Paul M. Clermont, FL
Good day to you All! I used this service for the first time this week. My enrollment counselor is pregnant and loves carmel apples. When she received her surprise gift today of your gourmet apples she was excited! She mentioned the large size of the apple, the fresh flavor coating the apple and the apple itself was superb! That made me feel good because she has been a pivotal force in my pursuit of education. I wanted to reward her accordingly and with your help WE made it happen! The pregnant woman was extremely pleased!! Thank you! - Monique A.
YOU GUYS AND LADIES ROCK!!! I LOVE MY APPLES! EVERY TIME THEY ARE DELIVERED, I'M LIKE A LITTLE KID...SO HAPPY! THANK YOU!!! :) YOU MAKE MY DAY! - GAYLE W, CLEARWATER, FL
I just wanted to let you know my story. I ordered an Easter apple as a gift for my son's girlfriend for Easter. It arrived yesterday and she called me screaming with excitement. She grew up in New Hampshire and had NEVER had a caramel apple before in her life! She was so excited. She said, and I quote, 'like an apple covered in caramel wouldn't be good enough, but then to have it covered in chocolate too, it's like something too good to believe'. My son was amazed that she had never had one either, and fondly told her stories of him growing up and actually MAKING homemade caramel apples. She was instantly jealous! Thanks for an amazing product and for introducing an East Coast girl to the delicacy called caramel apples!
- Sue R. Milwaukee, WI (a new and very satisfied customer)
Living right up the street from Amy's can be a dangerous thing! Cedarburg is lucky to have such a gem in our town. Even my 9 year old daughter is hooked on their animal shaped truffles. The apples really do taste even better than they look! Thanks, Amy's! - Pamela W. Cedarburg, WI
I ordered from Amy's for the first time about 3 years ago, and it has become my absolute favorite 'gift' to send. I've sent them for birthdays and special occasions. I even sent them to the realtor who sold my mother's home. The apples always get the same wonderful reaction from everyone. I must admit that I have tried them as well, and they are some of the freshest, most delicious caramel apples I have ever had. They are huge too, so they last for a while! The packaging makes the recipient feel very special with the gold box and ribbon. And besides, who doesn't like caramel apples???? Great product and wonderful packaging. A++++ in my book! - Cindy R. Fredericksburg, TX
By far the best caramel apples I have ever had! I have become a loyal customer and have gotten many others hooked on their delicious gourmet apples. The staff have always been pleasant and get you in and out quickly. - Jennifer A. Milwaukee, WI
Thank you so very much. I fretted and fretted over what to do for his birthday, then I found your site and immediately knew it was the perfect gift. I can't wait to get some for myself!!!! - Susanne.
Just wanted to let you know that we just received your apples. WOW! They are not just beautiful to look at they are delicious.....................We will definitely be ordering again............Thanks for a great product................. - Nancy R. - Milwaukee, WI
I would like to say Thank You for the beautiful basket. I purchased a basket for my significant other for Valentine's Day. He was so happy and surprised you made his day. As of now he still has not eaten any of the apples. He says he wants to admire them a little longer. - Lakima B.
Thank you for the prompt delivery and wonderful job on the apples I ordered for my girlfriend yesterday. She was so surprised and happy! They look beautiful and she said they are out of this world delicious. She was completely happy!!! Thank you! - Jen K. Chesterbrook, PA
Thank you for delivering the apples I ordered, they came on time and my god-daughters just LOVED them! My order was a great gift that I will do again! Thank-you again. - Candie H. Rotan, TX
Good Morning, I just wanted to pass along to you that the Gourmet Apples were a big hit! Very tasty as well - YUM :-) All the best. - Kimberly L, Baltimore, MD
I just wanted you all to know that the apples arrived on time, and the recipient, my Mom, enjoyed them very much. I will definitely order again in the future! Thank you very much. - Jacqueline L. Niagara Falls, NY
The apple arrived at my sister in law's today and she loved it!! Thanks. - Sharon T. Papillion, NE
I ordered some of your apples last week, after receiving one as a gift, and I also had a taste of some at a wedding. They are beautiful and soooo delicious. - Judith B. Sheboygan, WI
You are absolutely wonderful!! Thank you so much! - Linda S. Gallatin, TN
We received your apples as a gift and LOVED them! In fact we can stop thinking/dreaming about them. They were the best dessert we've ever had! With Valentines Day coming, I wanted to order some as a gift. - Melanie V. Marblehead, MA
I received an Amy's apple as a gift on Saturday. It was shear JOY eating this apple. Your apples are on the top of my list of things I miss about living in Wisconsin. - MaryLou P. Daleville, VA
Great apples! Better than any gourmet apples we have received from other places. My husbands favorite. Also my bridge club. - Mary S. Cedarburg, WI
I wanted to say Thank You. Amy's Apples were fantastic. I ordered some for family and friends from Amazon. Everyone loved them. Happy Holidays. - Maryann C, Miami, FL
I love chocolate. This is the best chocolate I have found in the entire USA. Not even kidding. When I was in Phoenix, there was an article in their Sunday paper about Amy's. In Phoenix's paper. Yeah. It's that good. - Kristin D. Jackson, WI
I just wanted to tell you that the apples I ordered were delivered today and everyone loved them. I have been ordering from your company for the last few years and want you to know that your products are impeccable and wonderful gifts that are always appreciated. - LORI D.
Just received a gift today from your company and loved it so much that I placed an order for my family for Christmas. Wonderful product. - Denise K.
I love these apples so much that my leadership team at work now gives them to our large department of caregivers (#80)each Fall. They actually run out of their work areas when they catch on to us coming down the hallway with our gourmet apple cart. They enjoy choosing just the right apple and now many of them are heading all the way from Sheboygan to Cedarburg just for the apples! U-Rock! - Laurie M.
By far the best chocolate we've ever had, and subsequently, no other chocolate will do. Amy's has spolied us and taught us how true chocolate should taste and feel. - Kim S.
'I recently ordered some apples through you guys and I just wanted to say THANK YOU! At a time where the mail system is busy it has been rare for me to have a company deliver when they say they will and for the product to be more than what I expected! I am extremely satisfies with my order and will use your business again and again! It's great to know there are still some reliable companies out there!! A very satisfied customer!!! :) - Jennifer W.'
'The 1st shipment arrived and the recipient raved over the freshness and great taste! I am thrilled so I ordered more. - Ann B.'
'Just received our order for Christmas. DELICIOUS!!! So divine. We'll be back! So fresh! - Terri.'
The apples are delicious. The apples themselves are crispy and juicy and sweet. The toppings are awesome and creative. We have found that they make great gifts (even for foodies) and are popular at parties. Don't take my word for it, they have been featured in the Wall Street Journal and on FoodTV. The truffles are really good too. And the service is pleasant and polite. This is one of the gems of Cedarburg! - Alfred W. Cedarburg, WI
We ordered a variety of the Christmas / Holiday apples for a corporate event and these apples were awesome! They were very delicious!! The snowman was the favorite of the taste testing and presentation! - Cathy P.
Sent a cashew apple to my mother-in-law for her b-day...BIG HIT! Thanks; she is tough to buy for...this one is for my sister's b-day (another hard-to-surprise person). Thanks for the great products...maybe I can get myself one someday! - Nancy H, Garland, TX
Simply outstanding. I wanted that caramel apple I remember as a kid and upon receiving, not only was I pleased....I want more. The caramel is outstanding and the apples are perfect. Cant wait for my next order! - STP P.
AND WOW! WHAT A PLEASANT SURPRISE. THEY ARE FANTASTIC AND THEY WERE BREAKFAST. Thanks for a great product. We will be ordering in future. - Richard & Lisa K, Egg Harbor Township, NJ
We just received a couple of apples as a gift from Dr. Tinnin in Fayetteville, AR-OMG!!!!! The most wonderfully fresh tasting beautiful gift!!! Just wanted to let you know that Monarch Dental in Fayetteville, AR LOVES YOU!!!! - Shannon R., AR
;) I LOVE Amy's. They had the coolest fall and halloween apples. One was caramel with white chocolate strips around it like a mummy and then eyes between two of the strips. They also had some decorated with gorgeous fall colored sugar leaves. I could spend a fortune there. I think I'd like working there...so creative! - Lana D.
There are no other gourmet apples that even approach the taste and quality of Amy's. I loved the special 6 pack of petite apples that you offered. I sent it as a gift for a family of six and they were wowed!! I also sent it to a family of 2 people that were wowed x 3. ha. Great bargain!! Kudos!! - Susan P, IL
The 'birthday girl' (recipient) and her family were absolutely blown away by the basket. I can't tell you how impressed they were with the size of the apples and the assortment of other goodies. THANK YOU! I'll be sure to recommend you to others & use you again when the occasion arises. - Kathleen, NY
Simply stated, the best Carmel/Candy Apples I have ever had. - Ryan H. Prospect Heights, IL
I will never understand why clients and colleagues continue to send me popcorn, truffles - and now caramel apples. Scotch, cigars, cognac, tickets to the symphony..bring it. But it's a well-known fact I'm not a general fan of sweets. Methinks they're sending a subtle message and trying to fatten me up.
Anyhow, several of these arrived today and the office went wild. They are simply enormous and the varieties - staggering. Dark chocolate turtle with pecans, macadamia coconut turtle, Belgian chocolate, caramel and crushed Oreos, double dunked chocolate, and caramel covered in M&Ms were just some of the types which arrived in a quantity which quickly caused grown men in our office to squeal like 12 year old boys.
Smartly packaged in copper-ish colour boxes and well-preserved in tissue, these divine treats are to be enjoyed and shared. I was terrified of eating one of these alone. Instead, I accepted a sliver here and there from employees who gleefully dug in. Yumm-ariffic.
I join the other reviewers here in awarding five stars, but alas....this is my first and last twirl on the dance floor with Amy's apples. - Koizumi Y. Winnetka, IL
WOW! My mom sent me a terrifically yummy surprise - 3 amy's apples! - and while i've had other particularly fantastic caramel apples, these, must say, are fantastic. the packaging, the quality - next time you have to gift something to someone perhaps hard to buy for, if they, say, eat food, you can't go wrong with these! :) - April C. South Pasadena, CA
My husband and I purchased an order from you this last September for our wedding in California which I wanted to thank you for. I'm still receiving cards from guests that are asking where the apples came from. They were such a hit! The order consisted of over 200 apples and they didn't only arrive on time, but they were well intact, carefully packed on ice and carefully packaged in their individual boxes. The apples were so fresh and will more than likely be the talk of the town for months to come. In fact, several guests have since placed their own orders. Your company was a pleasure to deal with and the staff was helpful and polite each time I called with questions. Thank you for everything. We will surely place orders with you in the future. - Morgan, CA
I just wanted to drop a quick note to say how lucky I feel to have found your company on the internet. Believe me, it was a by-chance find and I send your delicious apples to anyone who needs a pick me up. I recently sent Get Well apples to some friends, sent my niece and nephew two apples just because, sent another friend one after she broke her finger in a crazy accident, and then to my kids the JUST BECAUSE I LOVE YOU apples! LOL!
Keep up the good work, the tracking link is fantastic and everyone just raves about your product! - Kim U.
I FREAKING LOVE YOU GUYS - BEST WAY TO SEND A PRESENT (WAY TASTIER THAN FLOWERS) :) - Elizabeth H.
We ordered 7 or so apples for Valentine's Day for corporate gifts. They were amazing and we were very impressed. Usually our company prefers to buy locally from a candy store near us. However I am very pleased I talked them into using Amy's. The quality is excellent and the variety is great! - Brianne, CA
I absolutely LOVE caramel apples. My birthday was just on July 2nd and my sister ordered me the caramel & dark chocolate confetti apple. I wanted to take a minute to send an email and let you know what a treat it was...it was so delicious! I have had many caramel and chocolate apples from other companies and this one, by far, was my favorite. The caramel was out of this world and the dark chocolate was amazing...I'm such a dark chocolate lover. Not to mention it was so festively decorated for my birthday. Thanks for making such a yummy product...it was a very special present that I hope I now get every year!! - April Broad Brook, CT
First, when you stand in the doorway, there is a blower blowing out the most wonderful caramel smell ever. The windows are filled with more caramel apples than you can imagine. They put anything they can think of on them! However, we're not caramel apple people and $6-$10 per apple seems high even if they are amazing.
We go for the chocolates--esepecially the turtles--magnificent.
Wonderful! - Gretchen D. Chicago, IL